Motorcycle Accidents
How Fault Is Decided After an Oklahoma Motorcycle Crash
After a motorcycle crash, the question that decides almost everything is who was at fault, and by how much. Oklahoma does not treat fault as all or nothing. It assigns percentages, and those percentages decide whether you recover and how much. Riders face an added problem: insurers and juries sometimes assume the motorcycle must have been doing something wrong. Here is how fault is decided under Oklahoma law, and how to protect your claim. If you were hurt, our Tulsa motorcycle accident attorneys can review what happened.
Comparative negligence and the 51% rule
Oklahoma uses modified comparative negligence. Being partly at fault does not automatically end your claim. Instead, your damages are reduced in proportion to your share of fault, and you are barred from recovering only if your negligence is "of greater degree than" the negligence of the people who caused your injury (23 O.S. § 13 (opens in new tab)).
That is why it is often called the 51% rule. A few examples, assuming $100,000 in damages:
- Rider 0% at fault: recovers $100,000.
- Rider 20% at fault (for example, slightly over the speed limit): recovers $80,000.
- Rider 50% at fault: recovers $50,000.
- Rider 51% at fault: recovers nothing.
Every percentage point matters, which is why the other side will work hard to move fault toward the rider.
Each defendant pays its own share
When more than one party contributed to a crash, such as two drivers or a driver and a company responsible for a road hazard, Oklahoma generally makes each one liable only for the damages allocated to it, not the whole amount (23 O.S. § 15 (opens in new tab)). If a responsible party is left out of the case, or has no insurance, part of your loss may go unpaid. Your own uninsured motorist coverage can help fill that gap (36 O.S. § 3636 (opens in new tab)).
The riding laws insurers point to
When an insurer argues a rider was partly at fault, it usually relies on Oklahoma's motorcycle laws. Know what they actually say.
Helmets
Oklahoma requires helmets only for riders and passengers under 18 (47 O.S. § 12-609 (opens in new tab)). An adult who rides without a helmet is not breaking the law. Not wearing one also did not cause the crash, although an insurer may still argue it made a head injury worse. The same section requires a windshield or approved eye protection or a face shield.
Lane splitting
Oklahoma prohibits a motorcycle driver from passing other vehicles between lanes of traffic moving in the same direction (47 O.S. § 11-1103(D) (opens in new tab)). If a crash happened while a rider was splitting lanes, expect a significant share of fault to be assigned to the rider.
Speed and following distance
The same rules of the road apply to motorcycles as to cars. Speeding, following too closely or weaving between cars will be used to raise the rider's percentage of fault.
Common crashes where the other driver is usually at fault
Many motorcycle crashes follow familiar patterns in which the other driver bears most or all of the fault:
- A car turning left across the motorcycle's path at an intersection
- A driver changing lanes into a motorcycle in a blind spot
- A car pulling out from a driveway or side street
- A driver rear-ending a motorcycle stopped in traffic
- A car door opened into a rider's path
The defense in these cases is often "I didn't see the motorcycle." Not seeing a vehicle that was there to be seen is not a defense; it is usually the negligence.
The evidence that decides the percentages
Fault percentages are argued with evidence, so gather it early:
- Photos of the scene, the vehicles' final positions, skid marks and debris
- The police report and the officer's diagram
- Names and phone numbers of witnesses
- Helmet camera, dash camera or nearby business surveillance video, which is often overwritten within days
- Damage to your bike and gear, kept unrepaired until it has been documented
- Prompt medical records that connect your injuries to the crash
Our guide to the first 24 hours after a Tulsa crash walks through these steps in order.
Don't let the deadline pass
Most injury claims from a motorcycle crash must be filed within two years (12 O.S. § 95(A)(3) (opens in new tab)), and claims involving a government vehicle or road have a much shorter notice deadline. Read how long you have to file an injury claim in Oklahoma for the details.
Talk to someone who will fight the fault fight
Because every percentage point changes what you recover, the early investigation in a motorcycle case matters more than in almost any other injury claim. Smith Taylor, PLLC represents injured riders across Tulsa and Oklahoma. Learn more about our motorcycle accident practice, or call (918) 933-0123 to talk about your crash.