Contract Law

What You Have to Prove in an Oklahoma Breach of Contract Case

Gold line drawing of a signed contract on a dark background, cover for an article on proving breach of contract in Oklahoma

When a customer won't pay, a vendor doesn't deliver or a business partner walks away from a deal, the question is whether you have a case you can win. In Oklahoma, a breach of contract claim comes down to three elements, and each one is proved with evidence, usually paper. Here is what you need to show, how damages are measured and the deadlines that apply. If a deal has gone wrong, our Tulsa contract law attorneys can assess where you stand.

The three things you have to prove

Oklahoma courts generally require a plaintiff in a breach of contract case to prove:

  1. Formation: a valid, enforceable contract existed.
  2. Breach: the other party failed to do what the contract required.
  3. Damages: you suffered a loss as a direct result of the breach.

Missing any one of them can sink the case, even when it is obvious the other side behaved badly.

1. A contract was formed

Oklahoma law lists four essential elements of a contract: parties capable of contracting, their consent, a lawful object, and sufficient cause or consideration (15 O.S. § 2 (opens in new tab)). In plain terms: both sides agreed to definite terms, and each gave or promised something of value.

Written vs. oral agreements

Many oral agreements are enforceable, but they are harder to prove. Some contracts must be in writing to be enforced at all, including agreements that cannot be performed within one year, promises to pay someone else's debt, leases longer than one year and sales of real estate (15 O.S. § 136 (opens in new tab)). Even without a signed document, emails, text messages, invoices, purchase orders and a history of payments can show that a contract existed and what its terms were.

2. The other side breached it

A breach is a failure to perform a promise the contract required: not paying, not delivering, delivering late, doing defective work or doing something the contract prohibited. Expect the other side to argue one of these defenses:

  • You breached first, which may excuse their performance.
  • The contract doesn't say that, a dispute over what the terms mean.
  • The terms were changed by a later agreement, written or oral.
  • The breach was minor, not serious enough to justify what you did in response.

This is where the paper trail matters most. Keep the contract, every change order or amendment, and the communications showing what each side did and when.

3. The breach caused you damages

Oklahoma measures contract damages as the amount that will compensate you "for all the detriment proximately caused" by the breach, or that would likely result from it in the ordinary course of things. Damages must be clearly ascertainable in both their nature and origin (23 O.S. § 21 (opens in new tab)). In practice, that usually means:

  • The unpaid contract price or the cost of getting the work done by someone else
  • Out-of-pocket costs caused by the breach
  • Lost profits, when they can be proved with reasonable certainty

There is a ceiling: you cannot recover more than you would have gained if both sides had fully performed (23 O.S. § 96 (opens in new tab)). Speculative losses, and losses you could reasonably have avoided, are hard to recover. Records that tie each dollar to the breach are what make damages provable.

Attorney fees

Oklahoma generally follows the American rule: each side pays its own lawyers unless a statute or the contract says otherwise. Check your contract for a fee clause. By statute, the prevailing party may recover a reasonable attorney fee in actions over labor or services, open accounts, accounts stated, notes and contracts for the sale of goods (12 O.S. § 936 (opens in new tab)). That cuts both ways: if you sue under one of these categories and lose, you may owe the other side's fees.

Deadlines to sue

Read your contract for a shortened deadline, a notice requirement or an arbitration clause. Construction contracts carry their own, much shorter lien deadlines; see Oklahoma mechanics' lien deadlines every contractor should know.

Before you file

  • Gather the contract, amendments, invoices and all communications in one place.
  • Write down a timeline of who did what, and when.
  • Calculate your losses and keep the receipts that support each number.
  • Consider a written demand. It often resolves the dispute, and it creates a record if it doesn't.
  • Avoid steps that could be called your own breach, like stopping work or withholding payment, until you have advice.

Talk it through with a trial lawyer

Many contract disputes settle once the other side sees a well-documented claim from a firm that is ready to try it. Smith Taylor, PLLC handles contract disputes for businesses and individuals in Tulsa and across Oklahoma. Learn more about our contract law and civil litigation practices, or call (918) 933-0123 to talk about your dispute.

Questions about breach of contract in Oklahoma

What are the elements of a breach of contract claim in Oklahoma?

Generally: (1) a contract was formed, (2) the other party breached it, and (3) you suffered damages as a direct result. A contract itself requires parties capable of contracting, their consent, a lawful object, and sufficient consideration (15 O.S. § 2).

How long do I have to sue for breach of contract in Oklahoma?

Five years for a written contract and three years for a contract not in writing (12 O.S. § 95(A)(1)-(2)). For contracts for the sale of goods, five years from the breach, which the parties can shorten to no less than one year in their original agreement (12A O.S. § 2-725).

Is a verbal agreement enforceable in Oklahoma?

Often, yes, but some contracts must be in writing to be enforced, including agreements that cannot be performed within a year, promises to pay someone else's debt, leases longer than a year and sales of real estate (15 O.S. § 136).

Can I recover attorney fees in a contract case?

Oklahoma generally follows the American rule, so each side pays its own fees unless a statute or the contract says otherwise. One statute allows the prevailing party a reasonable fee in actions over labor or services, open accounts, notes and contracts for the sale of goods (12 O.S. § 936).

How are contract damages calculated?

By the amount that compensates for all the detriment the breach proximately caused, or that would likely result from it in the ordinary course (23 O.S. § 21), but never more than you would have gained if both sides had fully performed (23 O.S. § 96).

Request a consultation with Smith Taylor, PLLC

All fields are required. This form is protected by reCAPTCHA. See our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.

Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. Please do not send confidential or time-sensitive information through this form. An attorney-client relationship is established only by a signed written agreement.

Talk to a Tulsa Attorney About Your Situation

"This firm isn't a 'car wreck factory.' We don't take just any case with promises of dollar signs or freedom. We focus on quality over quantity, and I want each of my clients to know they will always be treated with dignity and respect, and they will never be just a number to me."

— Zach Smith

Request a Call Back

(918) 933-0123