Insurance Bad Faith
Signs Your Insurer Is Not Handling Your Claim in Good Faith
You paid your premiums so that the insurance company would be there when something went wrong. When a claim drags on for months, the offer makes no sense or the denial comes without an explanation, it is fair to ask whether the company is keeping its side of the deal. Oklahoma law expects insurers to treat their own policyholders fairly and in good faith. Here are the warning signs that yours may not be, and what the law requires. If your claim has stalled, our Tulsa insurance bad faith attorneys can review it.
What "good faith" means for an Oklahoma insurer
An insurance policy is a contract, but Oklahoma law treats the relationship as more than that. Insurers owe their own insureds a duty to deal fairly and act in good faith when handling claims, and Oklahoma courts have long allowed policyholders to sue when an insurer unreasonably refuses to pay, delays or denies a valid claim. The Legislature built the duty into the punitive damages statute, which expressly covers insurers that recklessly or intentionally breach their "duty to deal fairly and act in good faith with its insured" (23 O.S. § 9.1 (opens in new tab)).
Good faith does not mean the insurer has to pay every claim in full. An insurer can investigate, question the amount and deny claims that aren't covered. What it cannot do is act unreasonably, or put its own interests ahead of a fair evaluation of yours.
The warning signs
Oklahoma's Unfair Claims Settlement Practices Act lists conduct the state treats as unfair (36 O.S. § 1250.5 (opens in new tab)). Many of the most common warning signs track that list.
1. Unexplained delay
Once an insurer receives a properly completed proof of loss, it generally has 60 days to tell you whether the claim is accepted, denied or needs more investigation, with reasons if it needs more time. Investigations generally may not run past 120 days after proof of loss, except in cases of suspected fraud or arson (36 O.S. § 1250.7 (opens in new tab)). Repeated requests for documents you have already sent, unanswered calls and an adjuster who keeps changing are all red flags.
2. An offer far below what the claim is worth
Insurers may dispute value. But compelling policyholders to file suit by offering "substantially less" than what they ultimately recover, without just cause, is an unfair practice under the Act. A low offer with no explanation of how it was calculated deserves a written request for the basis.
3. No real investigation
Insurers must adopt reasonable standards for promptly investigating claims. Ignoring the medical records, repair estimates or photos you provide, or deciding before inspecting the damage, are signs the outcome was decided first.
4. Misrepresenting the policy
Knowingly misstating relevant facts or policy terms, or failing to disclose benefits that apply to your claim, are unfair practices. If an adjuster tells you something isn't covered, ask for the policy language in writing.
5. Not settling when liability is reasonably clear
When it is reasonably clear the insurer owes the claim, it must try in good faith to settle promptly and fairly. Holding out for no apparent reason is a warning sign.
6. Demanding a broader release than the claim
Requiring you to release more than the subject of the claim, for example releasing an injury claim to get your car repair paid, is listed as unfair. Read every release before you sign it.
7. Using technicalities that didn't hurt the insurer
Denying a claim because notice or proof of loss came late, when the delay caused the insurer no prejudice, is listed as unfair. For roof wind and hail claims, the Act also allows extra time to report damage that wasn't evident without an inspection.
Your own auto policy counts too
Bad faith claims usually involve your own insurer: homeowners, health, life, disability and auto coverage, including uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage (36 O.S. § 3636 (opens in new tab)). If you were hurt by an uninsured driver and your own company is treating you like an adversary, the same duty of good faith applies. Our guide to the first 24 hours after a Tulsa car accident explains how that coverage fits into a crash claim.
What to do if you see these signs
- Put everything in writing. Follow up every phone call with an email summarizing what was said.
- Keep a log. Dates you sent documents, who you spoke with and what they promised.
- Ask for reasons in writing. Request the basis for any denial or offer and the policy language relied on.
- Get a copy of your full policy, including the declarations page and endorsements.
- Don't sign a release until you understand exactly what it gives up.
- Consider a complaint with the Oklahoma Insurance Department (opens in new tab). It can prompt a response, but it is not a lawsuit and does not pause any legal deadline.
What a bad faith claim can recover
A successful bad faith claim can recover more than the policy benefits that were owed, including damages caused by the insurer's conduct. When a jury finds by clear and convincing evidence that an insurer acted with reckless disregard, or intentionally and with malice, punitive damages may be available within the limits Oklahoma law sets (23 O.S. § 9.1 (opens in new tab)).
Deadlines apply. Bad faith claims are generally treated as tort claims subject to a two-year limit (12 O.S. § 95(A)(3) (opens in new tab)), and your policy may set its own deadline for suing on the contract. Don't wait for the insurer to finish "reviewing" before you find out where you stand.
Talk to a lawyer before the insurer decides for you
Insurers handle claims every day with experienced adjusters and lawyers. You deal with one claim, often while recovering from an injury or a damaged home. Smith Taylor, PLLC represents policyholders in Tulsa and across Oklahoma. Learn more about our insurance bad faith practice, or call (918) 933-0123 to talk about your claim.